rich... | I think this is a reasonable trade agreement & hopefully shows our adversaries that we support Ukraine now & in the future. |
alda... | When you're between a rock and a hard place you do what you need to survive. I hope the deal is a favorable one. |
heat... | feels like its going to give trump what he wants and isnt to be trusted |
ande... | Any agreement that bolsters protection of European democracies against aggression by anti-democratic forces is most likely beneficial. I’m not a fan of this happening under duress the way it has. However, it’s somewhat ironic that the rare earth deposits that the Trump administration is seeking (to the extent they exist at all in economically viable concentrations) appear to be located in territory presently occupied by Russian forces. So in order to exploit those deposits under the deal we would first need to remove the Russian army. |
tris... | Hoping US backs Ukraine in fighting the war... Expect Trump to overshadow it all and hope our allies understand this situation . I hate saying I am American at this moment as I leave for Europe. |
sylv... | They have even up too much already. It Is greed showing to ask them to keep giving up things and for what. We have not helped them move on since Trump took office. What an embarrassment to ask them for anything. |
cind... | I would want Russia’s and Putin’s responses before deciding if this is good or bad or a scam. Putin never keeps his word and Trump is a compulsive liar so we’ll see how it goes. Zelenskyy is an honest and dedicated leader who deserves the same in return. |
nanc... | It’s a bit of a rebuke to Putin, as he has been against Ukraine joining the EU, plus the U.S. will not want to cede any resource-rich property to Russia, so it will be in their best interest to give Ukraine the tools they need to fight. |
geor... | We haven’t seen the entire document yet so I am not sure what it all means. I hope Ukraine gets America’s support against Putin as part of the deal and Trump doesn’t mess it all up! |
rgar... | Hopefully it will be a step to help end the war. It will provide support, money and jobs for Ukraine to recover. The US will getsome return for the investment we have made in the war and will make for Ukraine's future. It should be good for both countries. |
jhmi... | It’s greed. Plain and simple. A friend doesn’t ask for something in return for help. Shame on the Trump administration for this extortion. |
bmic... | Get rid of trump permanently |
ebr.... | I’m happy Ukraine will be okay but I’m disappointed in the US and Trump and his ilk. If President Zelenskyy is satisfied then so am I. Slava Ukraini |
then... | We need to help Ukraine gain back all of the territory they have lost, including Crimea. If we have access to their minerals and give them the military equipment in return, to push out Russia it will be beneficial to both countries. |
irvi... | It feels similar to mafia asking protection money. |
skea... | Hope it is a mutually beneficial agreement and that Ukraine got a fair shake. |
moni... | I worry about the fairness of the deal and unfortunately the US trying to manipulate Ukraine and not live up to its promises because this is how Donald Trump operates. |
kink... | Step in the right direction |
rodr... | Trump should have just helped with out that |
stbu... | Ukraine was invaded without cause |
brwa... | they own and operate mines in Southern West Virginia. A good employer and good corporate citizen |
mdul... | I'm saddened that Trump walked away from the US commitment to protect Ukraine from military force or economic coercion, as outlined in the Budapest Memorandum that led to Ukraine unilaterally disarming their nuclear arsenal. Zelensky had little choice but to pay the ransom to Trump even though he does not appear to have gotten anything for it in the form of ceasefire, return of captured lands, financial rebuilding assistance, or anything else. The deal shows the world that the US cannot be trusted and that has wide ranging future implications. However, the US will benefit from the proceeds of rare earth minerals and that will have benefit. |
k.si... | About time. Good for the Ukrainian. President to not be bullied by trump |
mdda... | If the U.S. agrees to support Ukraine with weapons in its war with Russia, I believe it to be a positive outcome for Ukraine and Europe and an affirmation of U.S. support for democracy. |
alic... | Will we keep our end of bargain? |
zaac... | Anyone who feels negative about this deal should start paying the bill for the Ukraine themselves. |
drba... | If it really strengthens Ukraine's war effort and encourages Ukraine to join NATO, I'm good with it. |
caro... | why would they trust the US at this point? Trump will just use this to allow more access to Russia….and continue to try to weaken Ukraine |
step... | It seems that the Ukrainian government is an honest broker that recognizes that there is no free lunch. But, they clearly didn’t give away the farm to the US. They have control of the land and the extractions. They have also likely secured a better US partner against Putin bc the US now has a vested interest. |
spkg... | I believe that the U.S. has to support Ukraine in its war against Russia. |
cb10... | Actually, not sure. |
gjla... | Trump never lives up to his end of the deal. I'm afraid that Uk. will not get the arms and support from trump that they need. Trump is in too deep with Putin and won't risk ticking Putin off. And which one of Trump's minions will be in charge of this project. |
spen... | Trump can not be trusted. Trump and Russia are against Ukraine |
rodf... | Dont know the details of the deal |
paul... | It looks good, but I don't trust trump; he is a pathological liar. |
cica... | We’re extorting them. |
cind... | At least we get something out of all we have given |
ibmi... | Retro extortion is a very odd thing to feel positive about. No guarantees? Is Ukraine being force-fed the actual, depreciated value of the arms support? ConOld Chump’s lie-based values? The full replacement cost of the arms (a scam)? |
koze... | Gives u some support and US presence there long term. Also ptivifrs uS with another source of minerals. May be s stepping stone to ending war.?? |
jllm... | Foot in the door |
falb... | Like the Giving Tree, Ukraine keeps giving and giving and we hero taking and taking. They have been our front line against expansionist Russia and we must support their independence ad well as profiting from their resources. |
wcrh... | Very few details, but if it means we will continue to aid Ukraine I’m for it. |
lora... | this is a brilliant idea by Trump. This will stop Russia's aggression on Ukraine since it will now entail US assets. Russia does not war with the US or NATO, so this is a good peaceful deterrent. |
deni... | I hated the bullying but the war needs to end, and with a vested commercial interest now in Ukraine perhaps the US will be a more predictable partner. |
neil... | Typical hegemonic move by the regime changing USA |
p_gs... | This is larger than the economics between the two countries and will support Ukraine's feedom at a critical period of the conflict against Russia. Longer term it signals joint U.S. and NATO support for stability of Ukraine's future. |
coll... | I'm afraid we may take advantage of them. |
join... | Ukraine gets our help fighting the Russian invasion, and we get something in return. Putin has been trying to appease Trump without making any concessions. It sounds like a good deal. |
olso... | This deal appears to be more fair to all parties, but tying our essential military aid to mineral interests feels a bit like we’re blackmailing a friend. |
gens... | I don’t care for trumps extortion |
jeff... | Hopefully this means continued support for Ukraine!!!! |
rsti... | The US should support Ukraine and put more pressure on Russia by all means possible. Trump is Putins puppet. Trump has been negotiating for Putin and almost demanding Ukraine surrender on Russias terms. That’s unacceptable |
drol... | If trump is involved it has to be shady |
karl... | Ukraine needs the support from the US, and the our nation needs to support European nations from the aggression of Russia. Russia is not our friend and unfortunately nations have lost trust in our nation! |
jame... | Deals should not be signed with allies at the point of a gun. It is a shameful experience. |
sims... | Hope it’s a win win not a trump bully move that hurt people of Ukraine in the long run. I am interested to see if trump will help Ukraine defend against russia. Trump and putin are buddies 🤔 |
newb... | The US needs to honour this and support Ukraine against Russia. |
atli... | This is the essence of Trump's art of the deal. Withhold something of existential value from your opponent until he is forced to agree. The rest of the world including Ukraine recognize the immorality of this arrangement but because of the power imbalance cannot do anything in the short-term to correct it. But, in the long term... |
9812... | Russia has only had very limited success in Ukraine I thought that Russia would have crushed Ukraine several years ago Russia has not and we, along with NATO partners, should not allow it to happen by cutting aid to Ukraine I would much rather expell the illegal aliens, then cut back on Federal and State aid as people find jobs. I am not sure if those people are anxious for a job but without public assistance it would be useful. |
jema... | I think it will be good for both countries, but I hope it will allow the US to resume military aid including long-range weapons and not just serve as payback for past assistance. Both the US and Ukraine desperately need Ukraine to win this war to stop Russian aggression! |
bilk... | Ukraine should not have to make a deal from an ally, who is part of NATO to assist them in war it’s more like extortion |
ayo.... | I worry for the future if the international rules-based order becomes transactional. |
jenn... | This is Trump being greedy and blackmailing Ukraine. " If you want US help, I want this". Just like tariffs, he is testing his power and seeing who retaliates. He is a bully. Help Ukraine for the lone fact that Russia invaded a great country. But why strip them of even more? |
gjok... | As long as trumpism rules the deal it cannot be a win win which it should be |
ham3... | After 64 billion we should own the country including the reaources. |
jwbe... | I feel that Ukraine has been milking us via Biden for years. We have taken way too much financial abuse. Let the other connected European countries step up and do their part. We have been screwed by the Ukranians, and if I were our President, I would tell them to go to hell! |
rhod... | Depends on how strong assurances of Ukraine safety is. |
gerh... | Signed contract or not - Trump can never be trusted about anything he promises or does. That's because his personality is a sickness that either himself, or anybody else can do anything about. He should be put under guardianship, before it's too late, for both USA and all the rest of the world. As anybody else who is seriously sick, cannot be kept responsible for being sick. No one wants to be sick. Only the people around the sick person are responsible to take response of the desaster he is causing before the katastrof becomes too irreversible. |
reds... | The concept is great and seems to be a positive development, however, I assume it will take 3-5 years before any minerals are extracted from Ukraine's earth and by then the U.S. will have a new POTUS that could likely "renege" or reverse any agreements. I also question the likelihood that Ukraine has the REMs that we long for. |
jcli... | Just hope trump sticks to the agreement |