In partnership with

Anna's Deep Dives

_{Just facts, you think for yourself}

 How are consumers really behaving as inflation bites and economic forecasts waver? Why does spending sometimes surge even when confidence plummets? What specific categories are thriving, and which are taking a hit in this unpredictable landscape?

The Consumer Conundrum of 2025.

Recent years have presented a whirlwind of economic shifts. In the U.S., March 2025 saw consumer confidence hit a 12-year low, with nearly 70% of Americans feeling the impact of inflation. Retail sales figures painted a mixed picture, with a modest 0.2% rise in February 2025 following a notable drop, falling short of expectations. Yet, amidst these concerns, consumer spending has shown surprising resilience, with reports from Visa and Mastercard indicating continued strength across various consumer segments.  

This apparent contradiction – where anxieties about rising prices, job security, and potential tariffs coexist with robust spending in certain areas – is at the heart of our latest deep dive. Many are left wondering how these seemingly conflicting trends can coexist and what they signal for the future.  

This deep dive unpacks the complexities of current consumer spending by:

• Setting the Stage: We explore the modern landscape of economic uncertainty, from global inflation pressures to the specific anxieties affecting U.S. households.  

• Analyzing the Macroeconomic Forces: We delve into how inflation across key categories like food and housing, shifts in monetary policy and interest rates, labor market dynamics, and global factors such as supply chain disruptions and tariffs are pressuring consumer wallets.  

• Understanding the Consumer Mindset: We examine consumer confidence indices, explore the "sentiment-spending gap" where negative feelings don't always translate to reduced spending, and discuss the psychological impacts influencing decision-making.  

• Mapping Spending Shifts: We identify where money is (and isn't) going, from the squeeze on essentials and cutbacks in discretionary areas to "selective splurging" on travel and experiences and the undeniable rise of value-seeking behaviors.  

• Focusing on Industry Impacts: We analyze how specific sectors—including retail, hospitality and travel, automotive and housing, and CPG/grocers —are adapting their strategies in response.

We don’t take shortcuts, chase headlines, or push narratives. We just bring you the news, straight and fair. If you value that, click here to become a paid subscriber—your support makes all the difference.

Table of Contents

^{(Click on any section to start reading it)}

I. Introduction: The Consumer in the Crosscurrents 

• Setting the Stage: The Modern Landscape of Economic Uncertainty 

• The Paradox: Why Consumer Spending Has Been More Resilient Than Expected 

• Defining Key Concepts: Inflation, Consumer Confidence, Discretionary vs. Essential Spending 

II. The Macroeconomic Backdrop: Forces Pressuring Consumer Wallets 

• Inflation's Grip: Tracking Price Increases Across Key Categories (Food, Energy, Housing) 

• The Role of Monetary Policy: Interest Rates, Borrowing Costs, and Access to Credit 

• Labor Market Dynamics: Employment Levels, Wage Growth, and Job Security Perceptions 

• Global Factors: Supply Chain Disruptions, Geopolitical Instability, and Tariff Impacts 

• Historical Context: Comparing Current Uncertainty to Past Economic Events (e.g., 2008 Crisis, Stagflation Periods)

III. The Consumer Mindset: Confidence, Sentiment, and Behavioral Shifts 

• Measuring the Mood: Understanding Consumer Confidence Indices (Conference Board, U. Michigan) and Recent Trends 

• The Sentiment-Spending Gap: Exploring Why Negative Feelings Haven't Always Translated to Reduced Spending 

• Psychological Impacts: How Uncertainty Influences Decision-Making (e.g., Risk Aversion, Value Focus, Delaying Purchases) 

• The Information Age: Media Influence and the Formation of Economic Expectations 

• Generational and Income Divides: Varying Responses to Economic Pressures

IV. Anatomy of Spending Shifts: Where the Money is (and Isn't) Going 

• The Squeeze on Essentials: Prioritizing Needs Amidst Rising Costs 

• The Discretionary Spending Spectrum: Cutbacks and Trade-Downs: Areas Facing Reduced Spending (e.g., certain retail goods, dining out) 

• Selective Splurging & Resilient Categories: Travel, Experiences, and "Little Treats" 

• The Quest for Value: The Rise of Discount Retailers, Private Labels, and Promotional Strategies 

• Channel Evolution: E-commerce Growth, Social Commerce Trends, and the Role of Brick-and-Mortar 

• Financial Health Check: Trends in Savings Rates, Debt Levels (Credit Cards, Loans), and Financial Vulnerability

V. Industry Focus: Sector Impacts and Business Strategies 

• Retail Realignment: Adapting to the Value-Conscious and Omni-Channel Shopper 

• Hospitality and Travel: Navigating Pent-Up Demand vs. Budget Constraints 

• Big-Ticket Items: Challenges in the Automotive, Housing, and Durables Markets 

• CPG and Grocers: Managing Inflation Pass-Through and Brand Loyalty 

• Strategic Adaptations: How Businesses Are Responding (Pricing, Marketing, Loyalty Programs, Supply Chain Adjustments, AI/Data Analytics)

VI. Looking Ahead: Future Outlook and Concluding Thoughts 

• Economic Scenarios for 2025 and Beyond: Potential Paths for Inflation, Growth, and Employment 

• Long-Term Behavioral Shifts: Will Current Trends Endure Post-Uncertainty? (e.g., Value Focus, Digital Adoption) 

• The Evolving Consumer Profile: Increased Intentionality, Focus on Value and Experience 

• Policy Implications: Potential Government and Central Bank Responses 

Baked with love,

Anna Eisenberg ❤️